- Fanboiz that love it for no apparent reason
- Fanboiz that would hate it for no apparent reason
- Everyone else that wouldn't care.
Let's see if I was right.
WIKIPEDIA POWAHS ACTIVATE!
"Reviews for GoldenEye 007 have been mostly positive."
Oooh, first blow against me...
"Frankly, I haven't seen a more impressive Wii shooter."
Note the use of 'Wii' there? That means there is better, but not on the Wii (just like GoldenEye for N64!)
"a lackluster game that fails to hit the same high notes of the original, or keep pace with modern shooters"
Huh, looks like I lost the first round but won the match, how about Metacritic?
Current score is 81, which is lower than the original by around 13 points... Highest score was 100; Lowest score was 58% which suggests a broad range of opinions. Innnnnnteresting. I'll take that as a point in my favour.
The comments I'm reading on various reviewer pages (metacritic and others) seem to roughly fall into two groups, those that like the wii version, and those that compare it to the N64 version and find it lacking. Another point in my favour.
...of course, it's hard to prove a lot of people don't care about it... or is it?
Let's look at sales numbers of the old and new game; based on this site (Goldeneye Wii, Goldeneye N64)
GoldenEye N64: 8Million+
GoldenEye Wii: 1,085,651
Granted, the older version has been out for a loooong time, but the Wii version has had nearly 6 months, I would think with the larger player base out there would make a great game sell a lot more copies, as a comparison, over roughly the same length of time Modern Warfare sold over 10 million copies on the XBox 360 alone (source).
Though, I should point out that I'm not fond of Modern Warfare either, but that is a story for another time...
Regardless, I claim victory, my only prize is the fuzzy feeling of rightness... or perhaps righteousness?
Let me say though, that I would have been happy to have been wrong; I want nothing more than good games to come out and for people to be entertained rather than disappointed, but before that can happen we as consumers must start refusing inferior products and demand more for our money.
Keeper3, I love being right, and I hate being right.
Next up, Dungeon Keeper.